نوع مقاله : مقاله علمی پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
The defendant's plea of "lack of knowledge," expressed through phrases such as "I do not know," occupies an ambiguous position in financial proceedings, and no clear ruling has been established for it in Iran's statutory laws. This silence in the statutory laws, coupled with differing opinions among Imamiyyah jurists regarding the nature and legal effects of such a response, may lead to conflicting judicial decisions. The central question of the present study is whether this response constitutes a denial, constitutes a refusal to take the oath, or represents an independent status that results in a stay of the proceedings. Employing a descriptive-analytical method and drawing upon Imami jurisprudential sources, this research has examined and evaluated three main viewpoints: "the ignorant defendant as a denier," "the ignorant defendant as a refuser," and "the stay of the proceedings." The findings indicate that the interpretation of the plea "I do not know" as a form of epistemological denial—which attaches the effects of denial to it and obligates the defendant to swear an oath negating knowledge—enjoys stronger jurisprudential and hadith-based support. According to this view, the ignorant defendant denies knowledge of the subject matter, not the underlying reality itself; therefore, he cannot swear an oath negating the reality, but is only obliged to swear an oath negating awareness of the existence of the right/claim. If this oath is taken, no financial judgment will be issued against him, and the claim will be stayed.
کلیدواژهها English