نوع مقاله : مقاله علمی پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
The relationship between artificial intelligence and the fundamental principles of Iran’s criminal justice has rarely been examined through field-based methods. This study aims to analyze the efficiency and the legal-jurisprudential challenges of employing artificial intelligence in the crime detection and prosecution stage, using a descriptive-analytical approach and a two-stage Delphi method with the participation of 48 experts in criminal law and information technology. The findings indicate that “crime scene reconstruction” and “face recognition” (mean = 3.23) have the highest perceived efficiency. However, face recognition shows the greatest dispersion of views (SD = 0.89) and, due to potential conflicts with the prohibition of unlawful surveillance (ḥurmāt tajassus), the right to privacy, and the rule of Taslīṭ (dominance), was evaluated as the most challenging function. In contrast, “criminal behavior prediction” has the lowest level of acceptance (mean = 2.64) and, because it conflicts with the presumption of innocence (principle 37 of the Constitution) and the rule of Darā’, cannot alone possess religious-legal (shar‘ī) or judicial authority for the attribution of a crime or the adoption of a criminal decision. The findings confirm the research hypothesis that technical efficiency alone is insufficient for legal-jurisprudential legitimacy, and that it is necessary to develop a local framework.
کلیدواژهها English