نوع مقاله : مقاله علمی پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
Medical advancements in sex reassignment have raised novel penal questions in Imāmī Fiqh and Iranian law. This study examines whether the subsequent sex reassignment of the victim (maqdhūf) affects the crime’s consummation, the perpetrator’s (qādhif) criminal liability, or the enforcement of the fixed penalty (ḥadd) in qadhf. Employing a descriptive-analytical method based on library research, this study analyzes the jurisprudence of sex reassignment alongside the constituent elements of qadhf, evaluating the victim’s transition across consummated (al-tāmm) and impossible (al-muḥāl) scenarios. Because qadhf is an instantaneous ḥadd offense, the decisive benchmark is the concurrence of statutory elements at the time of imputation (tempus delicti). In consummated qadhf, subsequent apparent transition cannot extinguish ḥadd; however, an actual transition revealing (kāshif) that an indispensable element was biologically impossible ab initio shifts the act to impossible qadhf. In impossible qadhf, liability never accrued, and subsequent transition cannot retroactively cure this defect. Subsequent transition per se does not remit liability; it carries legal effect solely when serving a retroactive declaratory function proving initial non-consummation. This conclusion strictly conforms to the principles of legality, strict penal interpretation, and the Dar’ doctrine.
کلیدواژهها English