نوع مقاله : مقاله علمی پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
The presumption of knowledge of the law is a legal fiction preserving the rule of law, public order, and legal certainty; however, its rigid application to all persons conflicts with justice. This study examines the scope of this presumption regarding foreign tourists and identifies criteria for limiting its effects. Employing an analytical-argumentative method with a critical approach, the research draws upon Islamic jurisprudence, legal doctrine, and supportive comparative analysis. The findings reveal that an absolute application of this presumption undermines commutative justice and the principle of Qubh-i 'Iqāb bi-lā Bayān (impermissibility of punishment without prior declaration). Accordingly, the paper proposes a tripartite model comprising two limiting criteria and one mitigating parameter: first, the nature of the rule, distinguishing intrinsically reprehensible crimes and fundamental public policy from mere regulatory and default rules; second, reasonable accessibility based on “objective availability” and “normative clarity and predictability,” considering tourists’ typical circumstances; and third, limiting parameters founded on good faith, legitimate expectations, and bona fide third-party vested rights. In private law, this model provides corrective remedies, including the restitution of undue payments and preservation of termination options; in criminal justice, relying on excusable ignorance (Jahl-i Qusūri) and the Dara’ principle, it negates mens rea or criminal liability, achieving judicial fairness without compromising the host state’s legal authority.
کلیدواژهها English